Despite what Church Says, Many Catholics Support Same-Sex Marriage

Gay Catholics

It's no secret that the institutional Catholic Church thinks that marriage equality is a sign of the end of days.  Witness the activism of the Catholic Church in Maine to take away the civil rights of gays and lesbians, or the outspokenness of Catholic politicos like Rick Santorum (who just this week sent out an appeal message for the National Organization for Marriage).

But here's the funny thing: despite what the institutional Church - the bishops, the Pope, the talking heads that get themselves on TV - says about same-sex marriage and LGBT rights, Catholics themselves as a whole seem to favor equal rights for gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender folks. The proof?

A religious scholar, Mark Silk, who took a Columbia University study examining support for same-sex marriage, and meshed it with a study analyzing religious identification.  When the two data sets are merged, one thing becomes clear.  Here's the juice, according to Silk:

Six of the eight states where 50 percent or more of the public supports gay marriage are the states with the highest proportion of Catholics, ranging from Rhode Island at 46 percent to New York and California at 37 percent.

Wow.  That may seem counter-intuitive, but there's also a bit of sweet justice involved there.  No matter how hard the Catholic Church as an institution campaigns against gay rights, the people in the pews aren't listening to the intolerance.  Instead, they're following their own instincts about faith and justice, which support inclusive rights for LGBT people.  Or so it seems.

Cathy Lynn Grossman at USA Today has this to say about the weird dichotomy at play here, between an institutional Church adamantly opposed to same-sex marriage, and a flock of followers who think that marriage equality is just another item in a line of civil rights due LGBT folks.

The bishops have campaigned long, loudly and clearly against same-sex marriage but the Catholic Church also offers a pervasive message of social justice, an umbrella many liberal Catholics stand under when they argue for marriage equality or life issues such as abortion, contraception and end-of-life decisions.

Well, to riff on the Rihanna song, that's an umbrella I'm willing to stand under :)

As for looking at the states most likely to support marriage equality in the coming months or year, one finds New York, New Jersey, and Rhode Island - three states that rank among the highest in terms of Catholic identity.  Interesting, indeed.

Vcygcorilljgafh-30x30-cropped Michael Jones

Michael Jones is a Change.org Editor.

He is the former Communications Director for the Human Rights Program at Harvard Law School, as well as the former Director of Communications for Pax Christi USA, a national Catholic peace and justice organization. Mike is a graduate of Syracuse University's S.I. Newhouse School of Public Communications and he is also a proud sketch comedy writer.

Comments (5)

  • Edwin Bonilla
    Jul 30, 2009 @ 05:08PM PT
    Edwin Bonilla

    It's great that many Catholics support the very important right of same-sex marriage. Although the leaders of the Catholic Church keep spewing their intolerance, their message is not correct and is why the Catholics who support LGBT rights have a correct view of it. With New York and New Jersey's high Catholic population, it does seem very likely that those states will recognize same-sex marriage in a few years, along with Rhode Island.

  • Gary Allmon
    Jul 30, 2009 @ 09:41PM PT
    Gary Allmon

    Protestants in general should recognize that Catholics (as human beings in the United States) are NOT stupid or intimidated by fraudulent teachings of the Catholic hierarchy.  For instance a large majority of Catholic families practice some form of birth control because they recognize that unrestrained procreation is a sure route to abject poverty.  Many Catholics in the United States recognize quite clearly that their religion as a "state supported" religion in Europe is an extremely weak position for any religion to be based upon.  Therefore, they support civil rights and a distinction between church and state.   Some U. S. Catholics might support their church's definition or even control of the rules of marriage but almost none would support their church's control of divorce.  Interesting dichotomy, huh?

  • Fester 60613
    Jul 31, 2009 @ 10:10AM PT
    Fester 60613

    The hierarchy of the RCC is revealing itself more and more as being out of touch with the reality of the human condition. Clueless.

    The **real** needs of **real** people are shunted aside for the same tired old theology: To the bishops and above, it's the afterlife that matters; it's the rites that matter; it's the pedagogy that matters.

    Since the revelation that it has been official Vatican policy to cover up sex-abuse (since the early 1960s!) the church has lost any moral authority it may once have attached to or had claimed for itself.

    The only value the church has is in its local priests and nuns - all of whom are enduring a witch hunt. The hierarchy cannot admit its own shortcomings, so they seek to pin the blame of their sins on those who are "on the ground".

    It will take hundreds of years for the chuch to fade away - but I truly believe that we have witnessed the beginning of the end for its tawdry misogynistic heads-up-the-ass leadership.

  • Ray Clark
    Aug 18, 2009 @ 02:12PM PT
    Ray Clark

    I notice the comments are coming from people who have no real understanding of the Catholic Faith. Insults, false accusations, dramatic emphases...none of these things touch the truth of this matter.  The truth of the matter is that there is no way the Catholic Church will follow in the footsteps of the offspring of the Protestant 'Reformation.'  Thanks be to God!  If there are persons out there who alledge that they are catholics but who deny the solemn teachings of the Church and agree with the folks commenting here that the leadership of the Church is out of touch, they are the ones who ought to consider more hospitable territory, maybe with the Episcopals.  If they think that they will stay and eventually undermine the Church's Sacred Tradition and Her Apostolic Teaching, they are wrong.  At some point God will supply those holy persons to rise to the defense of the Church.  I dare say that there are many millions awakening. Awake, you sleepers, Arise and put on Christ.

    • Chris Marshall
      Aug 18, 2009 @ 07:10PM PT
      Chris Marshall

      I hope the churches stay out of touch with reality Ray that way people can finally see religion for what it is. A whole load of bullshit, wrapped in an invisibility cloak of unreasonableness. Once we do it wont be hard moving, or mentally evolving out of it, if not outright banning it for its dangerous and destructive immoral views it teaches people.

    • Reverend Boony
      Oct 14, 2009 @ 04:25PM PT
      Reverend Boony

      Mr. clark...

      You are not a god or the god so therefor you dont get to decide who the real followers of jesus is...

       

    • Reply to thread
  • Robert Smith
    Nov 23, 2009 @ 12:00AM PT
    Robert Smith

    Sorry, no Catholic supports 'gay marriage'. Why? I am not a Jevohovah Witness because I don't believe what they believe. One may profess to be a Catholic, one may even go to church and pretend to be a catholic, but if one does not believe what the Catholic church teaches then by definition one is not Catholic because rightly or wrongly they have changed the teachings to suit themselves. I may not be a Catholic but I can respect the right of the Church to govern it's membership. The Church was founded to change it's membership, the members did not created to change the Church. They did not join the Church to change her, and if they did they were deceptive from the start. To call oneself one thing while proclaiming another is self delusion at best.

  • Add a Comment

    Comment Policy

    Comments on Change.org are meant for further exploration and evaluation of the ideas covered in the posts. To that end, we welcome constructive comments. However, we reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive, abusive, or off-topic; that contain ad hominem attacks; or that are designed to subvert or hijack comment threads rather than contribute to them. Repeat offenders may be permanently removed from the site at our discretion.

close

This user's Profile page is not public. They have restricted it to only their friends.

Already a Member?

Create an Account

You must create a Change.org account to complete this action. If you already have an account click here.

  Cancel