Gay Rights

Barney Frank is Wrong About the National Equality March. Here are Five Reasons Why.

Published October 11, 2009 @ 07:22AM PT

Barney Frank

Rep. Barney Frank may want to consider changing his name to Debbie Downer. Frank has become one of the most vocal critics of today's National Equality March, a gay rights demonstration in the nation's capital bringing thousands of activists around the country to rally for equal rights. For Frank, he'd rather see people stay home and work local connections on LGBT rights, instead of trying to nationalize the debate about LGBT equality.

"The only thing they're going to be putting pressure on is the grass," Frank told the AP in reference to the gay rights activists in D.C. He then challenged gay rights activists to think more like the AARP or the National Rifle Association (NRA).

But Frank misses the entire point of the National Equality March. The march certainly deserves to have its merits debated. I support it; many others do not. But to pre-label the march ineffective and cast doubt on the activism of the thousands of people in DC today is destructive, and frankly, Frank should no better (pun intended).

Here are our five reasons why Barney Frank is wrong about the National Equality March.

1. "It's been so long since the last national LGBT gathering that I wasn't even out of the closet then." That's a generic quote, but it can be attributed to thousands of people, especially younger folks, who weren't out of the closet in 2000 -- the year of the last national LGBT gathering. For these folks, there has never been a nationwide call for activism. Most of the folks that fit in this category just lived through one of the most homophobic presidencies of our time, and many want to see a sea change in gay rights now that the Bush administration has retired to Texas.

2. The point of the National Equality March is to motivate people to be active locally. Barney Frank wants people to stir change in their home communities, lobbying their own legislators on bills like the Employment Non-Discrimination Act (ENDA) and "Don't Ask, Don't Tell." That's exactly what the National Equality March hopes to achieve to -- bring people together for a weekend, and then send them home to capitalize on the momentum and passion from this weekend. As National Equality March organizer Kip Williams said, "We hear Congressman Frank when he says this is about getting back into your district and doing the work there. [This march] is about building community and building a network who will go back and do that work."

3. The possible extra momentum it might add for gay marriage in D.C. While many argue that the National Equality March takes away from efforts in Maine to fight back against an anti-gay ballot initiative to repeal same-sex marriage, the fact that thousands of activists are gathering in D.C. also has some significance for marriage equality. D.C. could be the next place in the country to recognize same-sex marriage. Having thousands of activists championing marriage equality in the city can only serve to promote that cause, and keep the issue alive and well and in the front pages of the traditional media.

4. Barney Frank is thinking about politics as if this were 1989. No offense to Barney Frank, who is the longest serving LGBT politician in Congress, but his mode of thinking about the National Equality March is out-dated. This march is a vision fueled by the netroots. The bulk of the organizing for this event seemed to take place online, from Facebook to Twitter, and it has engaged a new generation of activists who aren't tuned in to the organizational politics or activism of groups like the Human Rights Campaign or the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force. While those groups are critical, so too is the ability to organize young people and activists new to the cause. Join the Impact touched on this in the aftermath of Prop 8's passage, when they stepped up to organize nationwide demonstrations for equal rights, but there really is no nationwide grassroots group that can pour people out into the streets to fight for change. The National Equality March (and the continued work of Join the Impact) takes us closer to having that capability.

5. Obama deserves to hear from us. This may be the most sympathetic President we've ever had toward LGBT rights. But even in his speech last night, Obama challenged the gay rights movement not to let him forget we're out there. Obama said, "I also appreciate that many of you don’t believe that progress has come fast enough. It’s important to be honest among friends." Today's march, if anything, is that nudge to Obama that we're out there, we're watching, and if he thinks we're frustrated with the slow progress of things like "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" and repealing the Defense of Marriage Act now, wait until he sees what we're like in six months or twelve months if there's still no action on these things. Barney Frank is right that we need to work our local legislators so that they hear from us. But we also can't forget that Obama needs to hear from us, too.

Share this Post

Related Posts

Comments (8)

  1. Chris Marshall

    I can give you one reason about Frank.

    He's a pussy footing, limp wristed, cock-sucking, ball licking politician who does not have the balls to get off his ass, unless it is convenient for him, and fight for us.

    It does not matter if he is gay, just as it does not matter that Obama is half african american, folks these assholes are politicians, and this is no longer a federalist state like it once was; where hope and struggle can bring freedom. It is now a purely capitalist state, and who other than big business has nearly unlimited amounts of money? The church. So until we convince the churches or burn them all to the ground and strip them of their power we will never see these politicians stick their necks out for us; whether they be Ass or Elephant.

    Posted by Chris Marshall on 10/11/2009 @ 10:22AM PT

  2. Greg Goldgof

    The homophobic language in this comment makes me uncomfortable, even if it was not inteneded as such.

    Posted by Greg Goldgof on 10/12/2009 @ 04:10AM PT

    • Report close

      You must be signed in to report content.

    • 2 people like this comment.   Like
  3. Reply to thread
  4. Dave Hershey

    Michael,

    With all due respect, Frank is no longer deserving of respect. He defended Obama's DoJ DOMA brief (original.) Then he tells us to wait on our other issues. Who the hell is he to tell us to "wait." Especially when that wait is for nothing. Waiting for nothing is still = to, well........nothing. So in that regard Frank gets no respect from me. He is a traitor to the community that has supported him since his "coming out."

    All I can say is that Frank, like ALL politicians, is a sell-out!

    Posted by Dave Hershey on 10/11/2009 @ 01:55PM PT

  5. Edwin Bonilla

    The National Equality March was important and deserves the respect it deserves. Barney Frank should support the march in that it was to expand the support for the LGBT rights movement. It's good that the Washington, D.C. City Council will pass a bill which would recognize the very important right of same-sex marriage. President Obama supports much of LGBT rights, but should definitely support same-sex marriage, because it's about equality.

    Posted by Edwin Bonilla on 10/11/2009 @ 05:04PM PT

  6. Greg Goldgof

    Thanks for posting this Mike.

    I couldn't agree more with the first point. As a young person, I spent high school and college under the Bush administration. During this time there was never an impression that LGBT people could influence politics and get a positive outcome. Were it not for moving to California and the mobilization around Prop 8, I would probably still feel powerless. 

    We need to give our youth an understanding of the power each of them has and their responsibility to themselves to demand respect, demand equal treatment, and reshape the world.

    Posted by Greg Goldgof on 10/12/2009 @ 04:16AM PT

  7. Thomas McHugh

    Representative frank was indeed wrong to say that the march would be a waste of time although he has a point about local activism and about borrowing from other's successful playbooks...

    What he should have done, in my opinion, is exhort us all to not only march, not only campagn localy but to also use every other tool at our disposal in our fight for equality.

    Posted by Thomas McHugh on 10/12/2009 @ 04:23AM PT

  8. Bryan D. Freehling

    US Representative Barney Frank needs to shut up.  He is were is he is today thanks to all the gay and lesbian Americans who have MARCHED, SUFFERED and DIED since the Stonewall riot.  Liberation from discrimination and intolerance and true equality take time, and unfortunately, Mr. Frank has grown rather impatient.

    We should be thanking the powers that be, however, that President Obama was at one time a community organizer, because he certainly is multitasking like no other person could to resolve our numerous pressing domestic and international problems--many of which he inherited from George W. Bush.  We have among other things--an impaired economy, a sinking dollar, a sky-rocketing unemployment rate, health care reform around the corner, military engagement in two foreign countries…and I’m sure each of you who reads this could add a few other things to the list.  I think that it is commendable that Mr. Obama is doing as well as he is.  Let’s give the man a little credit here.  I mean, can you honestly imagine how slow Mr. Bush’s administration (or for that matter a McCain/Palin administration) would be at even acknowledging (let alone attempting to correct) these problems----and adressing all of this in his FIRST year of his FIRST term!!! 

    We accept and tolerate blindly too many things under a republican administration, but as soon as a democrat gets into office, our expectations are unrealistic, our PROJECTED annoyance from the previous administration rears itself, we become terribly impatient, and then we judge UNFAIRLY a man who is genuinely trying to better the lives of all Americans, mend our fragmented nation, and better the world we live in.  This is NOT the second coming, and President Obama is NOT Jesus Christ.  He is simply a man doing the best he can in an imperfect situation.

    I find it rather unusual that all of a sudden Mr. Frank has become quite boisterous with his venomous words directed at the National Equality March and at President Obama.  Where the hell was Mr. Frank the past 8 years when George W. Bush was in office?  The only person that I remember challenging Mr. Bush was US Representative Dennis Kucinich.  Mr. Kucinich seemed to be the ONLY person with enough CHUTZPAH to address the inequalities faced by gay and lesbian Americans, and he addressed the House in a move to impeach Mr. Bush for high crimes and misdemeanors.  And so now that we have an ally in the Oval Office, Mr. Frank decides to mount an attack!?  It would have been better for Mr. Frank to join the higher moral ground of Mr. Kucinich to fight against the true apathetic one---George W. Bush.

    Look, I would have preferred securing equality a long time ago, but I also recognize that the US is in a serious state of metamorphosis.   Inducing delivery of an underdeveloped fetus would only cause that fetus to die upon delivery.  The egg has already been fertilized by the sperm.  I want to carry my equal rights to term.  I want a successful birth--- a new beginning, but most importantly, I want my equal rights to usher in a new era, one free from toxic waste, intolerance, and persecution.  I want to make certain that my rights will be protected and perpetuated all across the USA through permanent legislation including a federal amendment to the US Constitution.  History reminds us that this has been the odyssey of  women and African-Americans seeking the same equality, and each time history has chronicled and confirmed the success of these groups.  If we truly desire permanent and perpetual equality for our kind, we must pursue it in this manner, and we must follow through in increments, otherwise we will end up aborting our equal rights, or experience a miscarriage and have to begin the process yet again.

    Posted by Bryan D. Freehling on 10/14/2009 @ 11:27PM PT

  9. Thomas McHugh

    Well said and good point mr. freehling.

    Posted by Thomas McHugh on 10/15/2009 @ 03:29PM PT

  10. Reply to thread

Add a Comment

For your comment to be published, you will need to confirm your email address after submitting your comment.

If you already have an account, click here to log in.

Comments on Change.org are meant for further exploration and evaluation of the ideas covered in the posts. To that end, we welcome constructive comments. However, we reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive, abusive, or off-topic; that contain ad hominem attacks; or that are designed to subvert or hijack comment threads rather than contribute to them. Repeat offenders may be permanently removed from the site at our discretion.

Author

Twitter Feed

Michael Jones

Michael is the Communications Director for the Human Rights Program at Harvard Law School, and previously was Communications Director for Pax Christi USA, a progressive Catholic human rights organization.

close

This user's Profile page is not public. They have restricted it to only their friends.

Already a Member?

Create an Account

You must create a Change.org account to complete this action.
If you already have an account click here.